Web guest checkout
Designing for trust, not just conversion
Context
A checkout redesign that helped Mercari, a peer-to-peer marketplace, recover lost sales and build user trust.
-
Role
Product designer
-
Team
Content designer, PM, BI, Eng
-
Duration
Nov 2023
The problem
40% of anonymous users abandoned checkout due to initial sign-up wall - costing ~$30M/month.
I was asked to reduce drop-off by letting guests complete purchases.
What’s causing 40% of users dropping off?
The obvious assumption was friction - simply asking user to signup was too much effort. But I wondered what were the visitors feeling emotionally? There was a core misalignment between business needs (retention) and user needs (wanting to try first).
I partnered with a user researcher to interview 10 guest users, and the concern of spamming and data security from guest users validated my hypothesis.
Quotes from user interview
It revealed that friction wasn’t the real blocker - trust was.
I reframed the problem and led improvements to form UX and strategic flow design.
Challenge #1
How might we design for trust for guest users?
Establishing baseline: Direct to guest checkout
To meet the brief quickly and set a testing baseline, the team and I implemented ‘direct to guest checkout’ flow.
Direct to checkout flow
It removed account creation entirely and let users complete a purchase instantly.
But it didn’t build trust or help with retention, so I treated it as a control variant for experimentation.
Audit checkout flow, test for optimization and trust
Working with cross-functional teams, we audited the checkout flow together and identified 3 opportunity areas to optimize UX.
The updated design focused on clarity, reassurance, and reducing cognitive load for first-time users.
The optimized checkout form was A/B tested against the direct to checkout flow. Result showed Optimized version increased order conversion by 20%.
Demonstrated that users checkout with more confident, and trust-diven UX moved the needle.
Challenge #2
How might balance user needs and business opportunity?
Balancing short term conversion and long term retention
Direct-to-checkout flow suffers because there’s no way to convert guests into registered users, and Mercari’s success depends on customer lifetime value.
I led competitive analysis to look for industry guest checkout pattern, and saw an opportunity to address registration prompt.
I designed 2 variants to A/B test: Button-based login vs Streamlined login. Results showed that Streamlined login increased sign-up rate by 15%.